Books by Sampo!

 

 

Support Us

Satellite News is not financially supported by Best Brains or any other entity. It is a labor of love, paid for out of our own pockets. If you value this site, we would be delighted if you showed it by making an occasional donation of any amount. Thanks.

Sampo & Erhardt

Sci-Fi Archives


Visit our archives of the MST3K pages previously hosted by the Sci-Fi Channel's SCIFI.COM.

Social Media


Weekend Discussion Thread: Alternate Actors in MSTed Movies?

Okay, I’m not exactly sure how this works, so you may have to help. Alert reader Andrew writes:

I think it’d be fun to have MSTies suggest alternate actors for the MST3k episodes.

Hmmm… Interesting, I think…

Some above-average MST3kInfo readers have been doing this already,

They have? I want details!

but let’s have a good, focused round-table. Not necessarily a better actor, just different.

Um, okay! I’m gonna go with: Burt Reynolds as The Master in “Manos.” Can’t you just hear that goofy laugh as he chases the family around the house?

97 Replies to “Weekend Discussion Thread: Alternate Actors in MSTed Movies?”

Commenting at Satellite News

We are determined to encourage thoughtful discussion, so please be respectful to others. We also provide an "Ignore" button () to help our users cope with "trolls" and other commenters whom they find annoying. Go to our Commenting Guidelines page for more details, including how to report offensive and spam commenting.

  1. Bob(NotThatBob) says:

    I see Bette Davis as the girlfriend in “Teenagers from Outer Space,” with John Goodman as grandpa, and Lisa Lampanelli as the lobster.

       0 likes

  2. drillerkiller1987 says:

    James Franco and Ellen Page in “SOOOOOOOULTAKER”! With Martin Sheen as “The Man”.

       0 likes

  3. Nutcase says:

    Stan McSerr, you win at life for saying Daffy Duck and Mitchel in the same sentance.

    As long as we’re talking cartoon/game/other fictional characters in any role for these turdbomb excuse for motion pictures, I have a few more to throw out:

    1: Webbigale (of Ducktales fame) as Lupita in Santa Claus (both are so innocent and sweet, it’s a perfect match)

    2: Dr. Ivo “Eggman” Robotnik as Bela Lugosi’s character in Bride of the Monster. (One scientist wants to make a “rice” of super beings and has a giant octopuss as a pet, while the other wants to turn the populace into robot slaves, and has a fixation on god-like beings of destruction)

    3: Ray Stanz as the lead character in Time Chasers. (fitting since both characters nearly brought the end of the world)

    4: King Bowser Koopa as Gamera (self explanatory)

    5: Splinter the Rat (Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles) in the place of Lee Van Cleef in the Master Ninja movies.

       0 likes

  4. crowschmo says:

    Russell Crowe as the Paper Chase guy in Warrior of the Lost World.

    Daniel Radcliffe as Mikey from Teenage Strangler.

       0 likes

  5. crowschmo says:

    Zach what’s-his-face from High School Musical as “It stinks!” guy from Pod People.

       0 likes

  6. shenloken says:

    The actual Nicholas Cage as Jerry from ‘The Incredibely Strange Creatures Who Stopped Living and Became Mixed Up Zombies!’ =-p

       0 likes

  7. Nicolletta says:

    A few more:

    Demi Moore as Batwoman and all the members of the Spice Girls, The Pussycat Dolls, and Bardot as the Batgirls.

    Michael J. Nelson as the Tab Hunter character in “San Francisco International”.

    Ashton Kutcher as Paul and Madonna as Kathy in “Track of the Moon Beast”.

    Benicio Del Toro as Paul and Ashlee Simpson-Wentz as Natalie in “Werewolf”. Hey, Benicio is starring in the remake of “The Wolf Man” and he looks like a werewolf in mid-transition anyway. He’s perfect!

    John C. Reilly as any Coleman Francis character. Except John C. Reilly actually has talent…

    Jackie Earle Haley as Torgo, Viggo Mortensen as The Master, and the cast of Desperate Housewives as the bickering wives in “Manos”.

       0 likes

  8. ck says:

    Daffy Duck as Mitchell is RIDICULOUS!
    Now, Bugs Bunny maybe. Or Perhaps Elmer Fudd.
    NO Wait! Think about the bedroom scene.
    It’s got to be Roger Rabbit and Dolores.
    Or perhaps Eddie.

    “[Eddie is hiding Roger in his pants]
    Dolores: Is that a rabbit in your pocket or are you just happy to see me?” :lol:

       0 likes

  9. Stan McSerr says:

    How about Adam West in drag as Batwoman, he probably would do it.

    ck is right, Not Daffy Duck as Mitchell, but rather Yosemite Sam. When Mitchell gets angry at the little Kid, I can just picture YS doing that part.

       0 likes

  10. peteywarren0829 says:

    Easily the best one so far has been John Goodman as Mitchell.

    Here’s a pair for you though, Will Ferrell and Toper Grace as the leads in “The Girl From Lover’s Lane.”

       0 likes

  11. Iggy Pop's Brother Steve Pop says:

    There’s just no end to the number of MSTed movies that Nicholas Cage in full-on crazy mode would improve.

    Margaret: Mike! Mike!

    Mike (Nicholas Cage): Just a sec, honey, I’ve found something! It’s… it’s Torgo’s hand! How’d it get burnt? HOW’D IT GET BURNT?!?! (punches Margaret in the face)

       0 likes

  12. Disco 3:16 says:

    Don Adams is Adam Chance in Agent For H.A.R.M.

    Paul Lynde is Arthur Duval (The Rich Dad) in Catalina Caper.

    Paris Hilton’s dignity is the creature in Monster A Go-Go. (Because, you see, there was no creature…)

       0 likes

  13. Robin Hood: Prince of Feebs says:

    I’m not sure why, but Hugh Jackman as Gary (Bob Boxbody) in Horrors of Spider Island.

       0 likes

  14. McBoddhi says:

    Jim Henson as the grizzled prospector in “Final Sacrifice”

    Don Knotts as Dropo in SCCTM

    Adam Sandler as that Ryder ‘Big Mclargehuge’ guy in Space Mutiny

    Patrick Swayze as Ator

       0 likes

  15. Sitting Duck says:

    Matthew Broderick as Jimmy Wilson in I Accuse My Parents.

       0 likes

  16. rob says:

    Professor Irwin Corey as the professor in the begining of the mole people

       0 likes

  17. Mr. B(ob) says:

    Bela Lugosi as Torgo and Boris Karloff as The Master in Manos: Hands Of Fate. It might have been genuinely creepy then instead of just weird and hilarious. Or go even weirder than the original and have R. Lee Ermey play The Master. “Now drop and give me twenty, maggot.”

    Stuart Margolin when he was a kid as Winky in Rocky Jones with Lee Marvin playing Rocky Jones. Seriously. Oh, and the gorgeous Jean Rogers (of original Flash Gordon serial fame) as Vena. Cleolanda I wouln’t change, perfect casting on that one.

    Have Gamera play Godzilla in Godzilla Vs. Megalon. ;)

       0 likes

  18. John A says:

    I vote Professor Bobo as the Boggy Creek Creature and a hearty second for John Goodman as Mitchell.

       0 likes

  19. DrChadFeelgood says:

    @#29

    I know Google says Tom DeSantis played Lurch in the “Addams Family” films, but that is simply incorrect. The name of the actor who played Lurch in the films with Raul Julia and Angelica Houston is Carel Struycken. And frankly, even though he does have the height and the huge head for it, I think he’s too sweet to play Eegah.

    Instead, since the character was supposed to be scary (I suppose?), I’d go with some hulking WWE star. The Undertaker, perhaps?

       0 likes

  20. DrChadFeelgood says:

    @#29

    I know Google says Tom DeSantis played Lurch in the “Addams Family” films, but that is simply incorrect. The name of the actor who played Lurch in the films with Raul Julia and Angelica Houston is Carel Struycken. And frankly, even though he does have the height and the huge head for it, I think he’s too sweet to play Eegah.

    Instead, since the character was supposed to be scary (I suppose?), I’d go with some hulking WWE star. The Undertaker, perhaps?

       0 likes

  21. DrChadFeelgood says:

    ECHO, echo!

    ECHO, echo!

    Sorry about that…

       0 likes

  22. kt says:

    Rita Moreno as that witch lady in …Zombies, or was that already Rita Moreno?

       0 likes

  23. dfd says:

    I just want to heartily endorse the idea of Bruce Campbell as Zap Rowsdower.

       0 likes

  24. mikek says:

    Time Chasers:

    Richard Dreyfuss – Nick

    Terri Garr – Lisa

    Kevin Spacey – J.K. Robertson

    Danny DeVito – Pink Boy

    Bruce Springsteen – Tony (whoever that guy is who works at the airport)

    Robert DeNiro – The Taxi Driver that comes from New York, New York.

    Charlotte Rae – The Old Lady who Nick meets in the grocery store.

    Red Zone Cuba:

    Griffin – John Goodman

    Cook – Harvey Keitel

    Landis – Steve Busceme

    Chastain – Johnny Depp

    Mrs. Chastain – Wynnona Ryder

       0 likes

  25. Fart Bargo says:

    My last recast; THE FINAL SACRIFICE

    Troy: Orlando Bloom
    Zap Rowsdower: Dennis Franz
    Satoris: Everret McGill
    Aunt Betty: Rhoseanne Bharr
    Mark Pipper: Shaggy voiced dubbed by Yosemite Sam

       0 likes

  26. Dereklap says:

    Prince of Space

    Prince–Chester Cheetah (wearing the face mask and shawl)

       0 likes

  27. Cabbage Patch Elvis says:

    Uma Thurman IS Diabolik!

       0 likes

  28. Keanu Reeves as Lance Fuller in “The She Creature”. Keanu has definitely read Fuller’s “Do Not Act” from cover to back.

       0 likes

  29. Cabbage Patch Elvis says:

    Crispen Glover IS Mr. Krasker!

       0 likes

  30. robot rump! says:

    my choice for Girl in Lover’s Lane:
    Big Stupid: Mark Wahlburg
    Danny: Shia LaBouf
    Carrie she’s so very: Jessica Simpson
    Jesse: either Danny DeVito or Rosie O’Donnell or possibly Rosie giving Danny a piggy back ride. either way you have the total repulsion factor, the lead female is in mortal danger at all times and as far as the wandering eye..just whack ’em in the head with a bat. effective and a little theraputic.

       0 likes

  31. robot rump! says:

    ok,ok…
    Riding With Death
    Sam aka Ben Murphy: David Hasselhoff
    Abby: Madonna
    Chief/ Big Daddy/ guy with really dirty glasses: Bill Shatner
    Buffalo Bill: Jim Carrey
    Cupcake: Drew Barrymore
    the elusive Mr. Denby: ehh Sam Waterson for some respectability.

       0 likes

  32. mikek says:

    “the elusive Mr. Denby: ehh Sam Waterson for some respectability.”

    Agreed. Pull him out of his cozy Law & Order/TD Ameritrade world and remind of the actor he used to be.

       0 likes

  33. ck says:

    Off topic (way off)

    World Series: Phillies in 6.

    Helpful advice to Yankee fans:
    “Leave the Bronx!” :smile:

       0 likes

  34. I'm not a medium, I'm a petite says:

    Phantom Planet and Charlton Heston.

    Heston as Ray “good and beautiful” Makonnen ( and maybe as Frank Chapman too ).

    Slaps the back of his neck, “god damn, you know captain, evet year of my life…… “

       0 likes

  35. Cabbage Patch Elvis says:

    #84 medium – Right on! I completely agree. Actually I could see Heston playing every role in Phantom Planet with ease. Except possibly Zeta. I’m just not sure Chuck could keep his trap shut for that long…

       0 likes

  36. ck says:

    Hmm Could there be a certain resemblance of Chuck Heston’s Moses to Sessom?

    It would certainly be a louder Sessom.

       0 likes

  37. Watch-out-for-Snakes says:

    Dr.ChadFeelgood. . . .
    Well don’t I feel silly. DAMN IMDB!! You’re right on who played Lurch in the Addams Family films, and Carel Struycken is too nice of a fella to play Eegah!, BUT, John DeSantis DID play Lurch on the short lived 90’s TV version of the Addams Family, AND I still think he would be perfect as a Eegah.

    Just check out his role as the Juggernaut ghost in Thirteen Ghosts (probably one of the cooler looking ghosts in that god awful film) as well as the Moonface killer in Don Coscarelli’s Incident On and Off a Mountain Road episode of Masters of Horror. No doubt in my mind he could pull off an Eegah role.

    And I am alone in the thought that Kurt Russell should play Arch Hall Jr.’s role in Eegah!?? I mean, Russell played Elvis in a movie years ago, and here he can play a Cabbage patch faced version of Elvis. I’d like to see Kurt with a hairstyle reminiscent of his cut from Big Trouble in Little China.

    Come on people, recognize divine hypothetical casting genius when it happens.

       0 likes

  38. Captain Jan says:

    We got this far without William Shatner?!

    How about Leonard Nimoy (with the beard) as The Great Virelli from “Devil Doll” with William Shatner as Hugo the dummy!

       0 likes

  39. Cabbage Patch Elvis says:

    I dunno about Kurt Russell as Arch Hall Jr. How about an early 1960’s version of Wayne Newton?

       0 likes

  40. MikeH says:

    Oh I’m gonna combine here cast from The Carol Burnett Show and Hal Needham actors:

    Harvey Korman as The Master
    Tim Conway as Torgo
    Burt Reynolds as Mike
    Loni Andersen as his wife
    Vicki Lawrence as the little girl (obviously she’d have to dress as a little girl)
    Valerie Perrine as The Master’s first wife
    Alf as the Master’s dog
    Dom Deluise as male teenager
    Madeline Kahn as female teenager

    And get Mel Brooks to direct

       0 likes

  41. MikeH says:

    I was also thinking also Tom Cruise as John Wikowski in The Starfighters

       0 likes

  42. MikeH says:

    Finally, in the last Gamera movie, Helen and Kenny (daddy I want a Coke)played by Donny and Marie Osmond

       0 likes

  43. ck says:

    “Dom Deluise as male teenager
    Madeline Kahn as female teenager

    And get Mel Brooks to direct”
    =========================
    And what’s the matter with Peter Boyle as the male teenager? (As the cops drive away they here Kahn singing)
    “Oh, sweet mystery of life at last I’ve found you!” (They obviously just had a roll in the hay).

       0 likes

  44. mando3B says:

    This is great!
    How ’bout Elmer Fudd as the hunter in “Bloodlust”? Or Fred Flintstone as Watney in “Outlaw”? Man, once you get started on this, you don’t want to stop . . . :twisted:

       0 likes

  45. bobhoncho says:

    #90, that is brilliant!

    As for me, I say Sofia Vergara as Lea in “Space Mutiny” and also as one of the ‘FOXES!’ in “Angels Revenge.” With her gorgeous boobs and butt, she would fit right in, and would probably steal the show.

       0 likes

  46. Ryan says:

    I haven’t followed professional wrestling on TV in fifteen years, but as a Botchamania mark, I’m familiar with El Generico. Ole…ole, ole…ole – ole-o-layyyyyyy!

    Tomas Milian as Castro in ‘Red Zone Cuba’
    Sean William Scott as Peter of ‘Devil Fish’

    That’s the best I can think of.

       0 likes

  47. Mike E. Jones says:

    I don’t have any suggestions but I would like to point out something to no. 74:
    —————————-
    Mrs. Chastain – Wynnona Ryder
    —————————-
    No. 74, your spelling is way off. Her first name is not spelled Wynnona it’s Winona, jeez.

       0 likes

Comments are closed.