What guest riffer would you like to have seen in the theater with Joel/Mike and bots, if it was possible? The two people that come to my mind would be Ernie Kovacs and the early Woody Allen (circa “What’s Up Tiger Lily?”). I think that they could have given the bots a run for their money.
Well, Groucho Marx would be the obvious choice. I’d also love to have any or all of the members of Firesign Theatre in the seats.
Who would you pick?
Richard Pryor..
3 likes
Episode: Samson vs. The Vampire Women
Guest riffer: Strong Bad
Result: Pretty hilarious
2 likes
I agree with the suggestion of Joe Bob Briggs, and would also like to suggest David Letterman.
2 likes
Ah, Joe Bob Briggs…For those who saw him do his own full-movie riffing (mixed with historical commentary) on the disk for “Jesse James Meets Frankenstein’s Daughter”. :)
Jonathan Winters you can’t riff with, you just sit back and listen in amazement. :)
And I assume @6 and @8 weren’t picking Michael Palin on the basis of his world-travel shows, but he’s got a quick wit for commentary:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y9jldGInh2k
2 likes
Joe Bob Briggs – the Legend
4 likes
Peter O’Toole
“If God could do the things we….ah, well. He did, didn’t he?”
1 likes
FOR GODS SAKE DON’T LET PEEWEE HERMAN IN THERE!
3 likes
Let’s face it:We’d ALL love to be the one in the theater ourselves, cracking jokes and having the times of our lives.
5 likes
Another vote for Paula Poundstone. She’s great on “Wait Wait Don’t Tell Me.” Excellent improv.
2 likes
H. L. Mencken
Mark Twain
2 likes
Doug Walker (aka That Guy with the Glasses) and Noah Antwiler (aka The Spoony One) are both excellent riffers and MST3K fans, as are quite a few of the other hosts at Doug’s website, thatguywiththeglasses.com.
Love some of the duo suggestions like Mitchell/Webb and Baratt/Fielding. Maybe Jemaine and Bret from Flight of the Conchords, too?
1 likes
@61 – Bret and Jermaine would be great! Nice pull.
This thread gave me an idea: when a movie comes out on DVD include an audio track with riffing by the MST guys, or have an MST alum sit in on the actual audio commentary. Wouldn’t this be a great selling point for Sci-Fi and Horror movies? Imagine if the upcoming Star Wars Blu Ray had a reunion of the MST cast to riff it, for example.
2 likes
I’m gonna second and third Mel Brooks.
Why do I have this feeling that there would be a lot of “Hello, boys!” riffs? :shock:
2 likes
Alright I withdraw Pee Wee and replace him with Sarah Silverman.
1 likes
I agree with any of the Monty Python crew. Might I add The Three Stooges.
2 likes
Charles Nelson Reilly !!!!
1 likes
Karl Pilkington, so he could make observations that no one else would. Don’t sit him next to Servo though because you wouldn’t be able to tell them apart.
1 likes
To be honest, I’m not too crazy about tampering with the basic MST3K recipe. Still, setting aside all our little Walter Mitty fantasies about joining in and just focusing on celebrities, I think I’d go with Craig Ferguson. He’s extremely sharp and funny and very good at just letting things pop out of his mouth. Much of his show is ad-libbed and hilarious and even when it isn’t working, his jokes about how it isn’t working work.
3 likes
Dan Castalanada and Hank Azaria would fit in perfectly!
3 likes
Love to see Mel Brooks. But also Nathon Fillion and Kevin Smith. Both there blogs are very funny.
2 likes
Kevin Smith and Jeff Anderson (Silent Bob and Randal from Clerks)
0 likes
@66 – Oh, so you’ve seen “The Life of Reilly”, too?:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3G-envKrYk
(Just watching Crow’s one-man Gene Rayburn show, one of the Brains HAD to have seen it before the fact. The parody of Reilly’s show is just too uncanny.)
0 likes
No one! I don’t like the guest riffers on Rifftrax! Stick with what works. Too many cooks spoil the broth.
2 likes
Doug: Actually, Groucho, Chico and Zeppo would make an awesome riffing team; Harpo would only be in the sketches, naturally.
Seconded. Now, if Harpo’s only in host segments, I guess that would make him the equivalent of Gypsy. I guess we know the real reason he doesn’t talk: he’s running the higher functions of the Marx Brothers.
3 likes
I vote for Bruce Campbell! He’s the B-Movie king and one funny guy.
7 likes
BoB and Ray would be great, they could ad-lib the most insane interviews, with the most unnecessary cruelty at odd moments. Chris Eliot or David Mirkin (from Get a Life & Simpsons)would be my second choices; they could all do great host segments, too.
Second nod for Dave Thomas/Rick Moranis.
For commentators (not comedians), I’d be curious to see how someone like Ann Coulter would do (on the polemic side) or Chas Krauthammer (on the dry side). Often the movies are so goofy, Joel or Mike just plays the ‘straight man’ to the silliness; a good straight man would do well, like maybe Tom Poston. (I’m dating my self, I’m really not that old…) Ernie Kovacs in silhouette would try all kinds of sight gags, I’m sure.
2 likes
Another vote for Richard Pryor. Uncensored. Oh, and alive.
1 likes
That’s easy: Joe Don Baker! Let him record a commentary for Mitchell or Final Justice, then bring in the guys (and gals) to riff the commentary.
Let the battle live on!
2 likes
#36, I think I prefer Steve Smith. Having seen him play his character live in Burien, Washington was a hoot. It’s just easier to get real riffers than fictional characters. And if you can add Patrick McKenna, that would be great also.
1 likes
Some interesting thoughts. Groucho, Mel Brooks, Dennis Miller, all would totally rock. I can just imagine what CNR could have done on a sword and sandals epic like Hercules. I could see Ryan Styles, Colin Mocherie, Josie Laurence and/or Tony Slattery helping out on a live riff.
I’d say me, but I’d hate to have my stint be “Oh yeah, that’s the one with that guy who didn’t seem to know what he was doing. Why was he there?”
0 likes
Anyone own the TEXAS CHAINSAW MASSACRE 2 Gruesome Edition DVD? The cast and crew commentary. Believe it or not, Bill Moseley is actually pretty funny while watching it. So are the others of course. But Bill guest riffing a horror film episode might have been interesting.
2 likes
Tina Fey and Amy Poehler.
3 likes
Now that I can think for myself, I would also add Joe Estevez. His interview on the SoulTaker disc was funny, and I think he would have a gift for it.
1 likes
Hmmmm. Dave Foley, Micheal Palin, Brian Regan, George Carlin, Ryan Stiles, Collin Mochery, Greg Proops, Eddie Izzard, Stephen Colbert, or maybe Demetri Martin.
3 likes
I vote for Jim Gaffigan.
1 likes
I’m going to go another route and say The Muppets, Stantler and Waldorf.
1 likes
Paul Lynde
2 likes
Trace Beaulieu or Mary Jo Pehl.
1 likes
Woops! Mary Jo was already a guest riffer. Loved her wih Bill riffing that X-Files movie!
1 likes
I could picture George Carlin, Dennis Miller, Chris Elliot, and Joel McHale all doing a great job riffing; while each has their own comedic styles, MST3K’s format allowed for varying tastes and attitudes to work.
1 likes
Mark Hamill or Seth Green. I think they would be very funny at it…
2 likes
Brian Regan or Jim Gaffigan. Some guy named Earl. Oh, and….. Chip Hitler.
4 likes
Christopher Guest and any of his usual suspects – Eugene Levy, Michael McKean, Harry Shearer, Catherine O’Hara, Michael Hitchcock, John Michael Higgins, Bob Balaban, Jane Lynch, Jennifer Coolidge and Fred Willard. throw in Joe Flaherty, too.
3 likes
I read Paul Lynde mentioned, and it made me wonder…how about a panel show with a classic assortment of celebrities from Hollywood Squares?
Charles Nelson Reilly of course, maybe Willie Tyler and Lester… the options are endless! The film could be paused as the audience votes on the best riff.
“Question – Torgo’s exaggerated physical attribute is—?”
Cue Paul Lynde :”His bippy!”
1 likes
Robin Williams would be fantastic as well as Christopher Titus Drew Carrey and his teamfrom Whose Line Is It Anyway would be Natural fits I’d say
1 likes
OH ALSO Who is the Really talented Voice Guy who was On Ren & Stimpy? Jerry or Billy West Just Awsome Also Ralph Garman who has a thousand voices and works with Kevin Smith on his Podcasts.
0 likes
Charles Manson and his “family”
1 likes
Jim Varney. He seemed very versatile as far as voices and character went.
2 likes
I would enjoy Stephen Colbert…
4 likes
Forrest Acerman, Boris Karloff, Bela Lugosi, John Carradine, Christopher Lee.
1 likes