Books by Sampo!

 

 

Support Us

Satellite News is not financially supported by Best Brains or any other entity. It is a labor of love, paid for out of our own pockets. If you value this site, we would be delighted if you showed it by making an occasional donation of any amount. Thanks.

Sampo & Erhardt

Sci-Fi Archives


Visit our archives of the MST3K pages previously hosted by the Sci-Fi Channel's SCIFI.COM.

Social Media


Weekend Discussion Thread: ‘Say What?’

A certain regular who asked not to be named opines:

[Recently], several of us [commenters in a certain thread] were commenting about how silly the spam messages were, which you’ve since deleted. They sounded like something weirdly translated into English, and I said this might be a good WDT, perhaps call it, “Say WHAT?” — sentences spoken by an MST3K character that make no sense whatsoever. I don’t mean sentences that are hard to hear or understand, like Buffalo Bill’s “New England journalists!” in “Riding with Death” (which I think was a redneck accented way of saying, “You act like you’re enjoying this,” by the way).

My “Say what??” would be from “Agent for H.A.R.M.” when Adam Chance says, “You think you can’t get hurt, Doctor, because this is America? Apple pie and all that jazz? Well, it’s my job to keep the pie on the table, and nobody asks me how I do it!” Why pie? Why does Chance have to keep it on the table? Where else would it be? My brain hurts…

I’ve got a classic: “Flag on the moon. How did it get there?” WHA? Ya wanna unpack that one for me, there, Coleman, buddy?

What’s your pick?

98 Replies to “Weekend Discussion Thread: ‘Say What?’”

Commenting at Satellite News

We are determined to encourage thoughtful discussion, so please be respectful to others. We also provide an "Ignore" button () to help our users cope with "trolls" and other commenters whom they find annoying. Go to our Commenting Guidelines page for more details, including how to report offensive and spam commenting.

  1. HauntedHill says:

    I’ll go with “Pretty, you may be!” from The Projected Man. It’s just so odd and abrupt, it really seems to set the tone for the rest of the movie. And as far as Coleman Francis goes, almost EVERY line of ‘narration’ from Beast of Yucca Flats could quality. “Flag on the Moon…” was a fine opening choice.

       17 likes

  2. robot rump! says:

    Although the rest of the movie is crystal clear and well thought out, the last line of ‘Red Zone Cuba’ “He ran all the way to hell, with a penny and a broken cigarette.” just didn’t have the impact for me as a closing line. Maybe I’m the only one who just didn’t get it. A slight improvement might have been if oh let’s say Coleman falls down next to a sled and whispers “Cherokee Jaaack!” “Cherokee Jaacck!”

       10 likes

  3. the_dumpster says:

    So, basically, every weekend discussion will have (and has, so far) the response “Flag on the moon. How did it get there?”

    Seems to be the default.

       10 likes

  4. jaybird3rd says:

    My favorite “sentence that makes no sense” is from “Fire Maidens of Outer Space”: as the two astronomers are in the observatory (built inside a bus station), smoking like fiends and discussing the possibility of life on the 13th moon of Jupiter, the Anthony Dexter character says “It’s probable, but highly doubtful.” What???

       12 likes

  5. DarkGrandmaofDeath says:

    #3, is that such a bad thing? It certainly fits this week’s topic.

    Maybe it can be our version of “I thought you were Dale.”

       11 likes

  6. jjb3k says:

    Overdrawn at the Memory Bank is full of these: “The whole world’s in sixes and sevens, sonny!”, “Your navel’s very deep, Fingal! So deep I can’t even see to the bottom!”, etc. The whole script sounds like it was written by someone who didn’t have English as their first language.

    Another one of my favorites comes from Time of the Apes, when Catherine is concerned about the earthquakes, and the doctor says “Yes, but nothing will happen suddenly.” What the hell does that even mean?

       13 likes

  7. The Mighty Untrained FOOZLE says:

    “…and traffic accidents…”

       12 likes

  8. Kansas says:

    In Leech Woman, Mala talks about her dreams of blood (presumably to tie in with the movie’s title) and yet there is no real bloodshed involved. Shouldn’t it have been dreams of pineal fluid?

       9 likes

  9. 1ONE says:

    I have to go with Mikey from “Teen-Age Strangler”

    “And he didn’t steal no bike neither…I did, he just wanted to..!”

    Can be assessed best by Mike’s response (as the Police Officer) “Good Lord, who is this clown?’

       12 likes

  10. jaybird3rd says:

    Wow, the poorly translated and dubbed Japanese movies are a whole other level of dialog that makes no sense. It’s like they took a bad Google translation, chopped it up with scissors, and pasted it onto the movie at random.

    For me, it doesn’t get any better than the press conference at the beginning of “Gamera vs. Guiron”:

    Reporter: “Does that mean … people on Solar … are the same system planet?”
    Dr. Shiga: “No. That’s hard to say.”

    :-?

       17 likes

  11. 1ONE says:

    I have another one… from “The Human Duplicators”

    Professor Dornheimer: “As you have already seen, my life is not the dull routine the general public might imagine”.

    Glenn Martin: “No, your niece is lovely”.

    Summed up best by Joel: “What the HELL Is that supposed to mean??”

       19 likes

  12. agentmom says:

    All I can think of is Akio’s fixation on Traffic Accidents in “Gamera vs. Guiron.” That was always a “What???? Traffic Accidents??, to me! Oh heck, 7 beat me to it!

       5 likes

  13. Fart Bargo says:

    I’ll go with the Phantom of Krankor when he threatens to “kill some differin!”. Oh, yes, shooting the Prince over and over and over again despite the obvious uselessness of their weapons. I could go on and on and on …

       5 likes

  14. Leave Crow T. Robert Denby Alone says:

    “Everybody who goes there, doesn’t talk!” Puma Man

       9 likes

  15. saherrin says:

    I am going to go with whatever the trumpeter said in Hellcats (they even made a stinger out of it.) It was a running joke (almost literally) but I would also nominate Timothy Van Patten’s inner mono logue in Master Ninja II (the union episode…I mean half of the movie.)

       4 likes

  16. Huggybear says:

    Mine is from Pod People. When renaissance guy is chasing the boyfriends girlfreind, the old Lorne Greene guy yells “well you’re a jerk”!

       3 likes

  17. Kenneth Morgan says:

    I realize the question is about MST3K specifically, but I can’t help but offer this:

    “If we learn to care for others, to respect others will learn how to care for, to respect our country.”

       8 likes

  18. Sitting Duck says:

    Mine is from The Robot Vs. The Aztec Mummy, when The Bat refers to his creation as a human robot. The hell?

       3 likes

  19. MarcusVermilion says:

    That whole “Pretty Mind” speech from “Girl in Gold Boots”.

       11 likes

  20. Remmie Barrow says:

    How about “Watch out for snakes” from EEGHA! It totally comes out from nowhere.

       9 likes

  21. Viking Woman says:

    “This is where the fish lives.”
    -Touch of Satan

    Uhh… huh? What does that have to do with anything? Why one singular fish? Why is that fish’s habitat so important to mention? I can’t even begin to make sense of this line and why it exists. I’m so glad it does, though, as it and all the riffs concerning it are part of why that episode is my absolute favorite.

    “This is where my TONGUE lives…”
    “My Fish moved and didn’t leave a forwarding address.”

       23 likes

  22. Son of Peanut says:

    From Red Zone Cuba – “She’s been blind, ya know, since her husband got killed in the war.” Quite possibly my favorite line from any MSTied movie, and no riffing was even needed.

    Honorable mention from Werewolf – “You and Noel is in it for fame and fortune?”

       18 likes

  23. Mibbitmaker says:

    The entire movie Monster a Go Go, especially the closing narration. “Say whaaaat?”, indeed!

       5 likes

  24. Black Doug says:

    I have to agree with “traffic accidents”… especially since, as I understand it, those were the actual lines in the Japanese original as well, so that’s not even Sandy Frank’s fault.

    Also, the opening narration in “Why Study Industrial Arts” tends to get a “wait, what?” reaction out of me. Mike and the bots have it pegged–that kid is one pissed-in-bed away from being a potential serial killer.

       3 likes

  25. trickymutha says:

    The whole cracker thing in episode 704 is pretty out there.

       4 likes

  26. Dr. Erickson says:

    “Once you two are married it won’t be fun to watch anymore.” – The Thing that Wouldn’t Die
    “Nothing bothers some people, not even flying saucers.” (???!!!) – Beast of Yucca Flats

    Best though comes from Sam the Keeper: “I just found out Count Dracula was a f*g. You don’t have to believe me, but that’s the facts.” – Werewolf

       14 likes

  27. rose from nj says:

    The father from “Sampson vs. the Vampire Women” inviting the inspector to his home and then refusing to explain anything about the situation was hysterically funny riff-wise, but made no sense on its own.

       14 likes

  28. ck says:

    Has to be one of the biker gang (in Hellcats?) who is thrown into
    the stream and yells out some gibberish, I believe the actual line was
    “You chums have behaved bloody cheeky tossing me in this bucolic stream,
    what?” Wasn’t it the stinger in that episode?

       4 likes

  29. Insect Man #47 says:

    The first one I thought of was the doctor in “Amazing Colossal Man”, who told us that the heart is made up of a single cell. That certainly puts to shame every biology text book ever written.

       15 likes

  30. Black Doug says:

    #26: If the upcoming “Dracula Untold” doesn’t portray Vlad Dracul’s homosexuality as per Sam the Keeper’s theories, I’ll have to call shenanigans.

       3 likes

  31. Murdock Hauser says:

    From “Sinster Urge”

    Lt. Matt Carson: Mr. Taxpayer the smut picture racket is worst then kidnapping and dope peddling.

    Crow: No it isn’t!

       12 likes

  32. Meme Deadhorsebeater says:

    A little OT, but did we ever get a transcript of the lyrics of the song in Pod People, or any information on whatever it was in the original (Spanish?) version?

    That’s like the boring but informative Mirror Universe version of this thread, I guess- misheard/mumbled dialogue reconstructed or explained. Could also be expanded to plot threads from movies before they were translated/dubbed or edited down.

    Anyway, my vote is for the explanation of the Interocitor from The Movie. Granted, it’s shown as a communications device and also a weapon, but Cal also says it (or a bigger version?) could lay highway at a mile a minute. Yes, alien superscience, but still. The hell?

       3 likes

  33. VeryDisturbing says:

    Everything that VanPatton kid says in the Master Ninja movies is a ‘Say What!?’.
    Every. Single. Line.

    Scabbaflabbadabbadee…

       6 likes

  34. Blowie the Dolphin says:

    In “Phantom Planet, when Lt. Makonnen gives his “best and wisest” speech. Uh, what?
    Even Frank Chapman can’t understand it.

       14 likes

  35. Thomas K. Dye says:

    One thing no one ever notices in “Fire Maidens of Outer Space” because Joel riffs right over it… Anthony Dexter and the Fire Maiden are talking.

    HESTIA: Here the only sound is of the ripple of tiny waves on the lake.
    DEXTER: What’s the name of the lake?
    HESTIA: Prossus holds us all prisoners! He has the power of life or death on New Atlantis!

    Fire Maiden apparently didn’t even want to bother answering such a boring question.

       9 likes

  36. Mr B. Natural: “Knew your father I did.”
    Um, what does she/he/it mean by that?

       6 likes

  37. jaybird3rd says:

    @#35: I noticed that, too. Later he also asks her “Do you have seasons here?” (which, of course, Joel spins into a “Seasons in the Sun” riff). What I think is happening in that scene is that they’re both keeping their voices low as they discuss Prasus and their escape plans, while he peppers the conversation with mundane questions spoken more loudly, in case Prasus is listening in. It doesn’t come across very well on the screen, but then, nothing else in “Fire Maidens of Outer Space” comes across very well, either. A cut to a hidden microphone or to Prasus listening through his ring or something would have clarified it, instead of just a lazy static shot of Anthony Dexter and Susan Shaw. I blame Cy Roth.

       7 likes

  38. Mary Arline says:

    From Soultaker, one of the cops at the scene of the car crash says, “So what do you figure the chances are of a door opening by itself on impact in a head-on collision?” Um, is this his first car crash? Crow correctly observes that the chances are actually “quite good.”

       18 likes

  39. Castleton Snob says:

    Is that stud coming?

       20 likes

  40. Dr. Erickson says:

    Remembered another favorite from Puma Man: “So, the dinosaurs became extinct because they forgot how to love.” I always think to myself, What the hell book is she reading?

       16 likes

  41. Rob says:

    I’m going to echo the niece line from The Human Duplicators. Cause, wha’?

    Not related, but similar, watching Monster-a-Go-Go the other night once again has me wondering where the “um-da-do-do-do hu-ah, hu-ah” thing comes from. It’s my biggest show mystery! It probably doesn’t help that it’s the “Sent Email” sound on my phone, too, so I hear it a lot.

       4 likes

  42. Steve Vil says:

    “I’m comiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiing!” from Quest Of The Delta Knights. Not sure why we needed to know that.

    Of the entire argument between Mitchell and the kid who skateboards past: “You’re lying through your teeth!” Who is? It was a completely random comment in a completelyer randomer conversation.

       11 likes

  43. “Come on boys and carry my bananas!”

    -from Untamed Youth


    Sure, it’s from a song (the closing calypso number), and song lyrics can sometimes be nonsensical and still carry weight, but in this case I find myself having the same reaction as Joel does: “WHAT does that mean??”
    :-/

       4 likes

  44. EricJ says:

    Untamed Youth:
    (girls’ catfight) “C’mon, if you want an Italian haircut!”
    Servo: “Extra mousse? I dunno…”

       7 likes

  45. Professor Firefly says:

    Would stemlo be considered a word or just a sound? Seems like something Eegah said quite a bit,doesn’t it?

       1 likes

  46. Flying Saucers Over Oz says:

    And of course there’s the old warhorse of these things from Ed Wood’s BRIDE OF THE MONSTER…

    “Monsters! Hah! This is the Twentieth Century!”
    “Don’t count on it!”

    Or even from GAMERA VS GUIRON…

    “Gaos is a different color! He must be a space Gaos!”

    Um… Okay… I suppose…

       6 likes

  47. ready4sumfootball says:

    The censored lines in Final Justice. “Son of a what? A sailor? Son of a preacher man?”

       1 likes

  48. underwoc says:

    Most of the plot for Wild Wild World of Batwoman is non-sensical, but if I may go off topic slightly… What the hell is going on with that horseshoe?

       3 likes

  49. Spade says:

    In Space Mutiny, when the mutineers are talking about landing the ship:

    “It’s true! We have the power to do this! But this would directly oppose the law of the universe, the law of the galaxy.” (It would?!?!)

    And I strongly second #34 – that speech about “the wisest and best” in Phantom Planet really comes out of nowhere, and seems apropos of nothing.

    Finally, Pod People has a lot of truly awful dialog, so it was inevitable that they’d have at least a couple of these kinds of lines:

    “Making out with chicks is part of his act as an artist.” (?!?!?)

    “I guess I’ll just have to find a ranger or a bear to sleep with then.” (prompting Servo’s quietly horrified “What are you saying??”)

       10 likes

  50. Leave Crow T. Robert Denby Alone says:

    Sheriff to Johnny Longbow: “Whatever.”

       3 likes

Comments are closed.