Books by Sampo!

 

 

Support Us

Satellite News is not financially supported by Best Brains or any other entity. It is a labor of love, paid for out of our own pockets. If you value this site, we would be delighted if you showed it by making an occasional donation of any amount. Thanks.

Sampo & Erhardt

Sci-Fi Archives


Visit our archives of the MST3K pages previously hosted by the Sci-Fi Channel's SCIFI.COM.

Social Media


Weekend Discussion Thread: MSTed Movie to Broadway?

Longtime MSTie Charlie asks:

Which MST movie should be made into a broadway musical?

Hey, if “Spiderman: Turn Off the Dark” can be wrestled into acceptable form, lots of other movies might be adapted. My pick would be “Teenagers from Outer Space.” You got the sensible heroine, the misunderstood hero, the wacky grandpa and the terrifying lobster creatures! I smell a hit!

What’s your pick?

121 Replies to “Weekend Discussion Thread: MSTed Movie to Broadway?”

Commenting at Satellite News

We are determined to encourage thoughtful discussion, so please be respectful to others. We also provide an "Ignore" button () to help our users cope with "trolls" and other commenters whom they find annoying. Go to our Commenting Guidelines page for more details, including how to report offensive and spam commenting.

  1. I would say The Beatniks or perhaps Wild Rebels.

       1 likes

  2. Ralph C. says:

    MST3K: The Movie.

       1 likes

  3. big61al says:

    The girl in the gold boots

       3 likes

  4. Invasion of the Neptune Man says:

    Space Mutiny. Big Large McHugh, Captain Santa, 1st Officer Sting, the Stevie Nicks look-a-likes, lots of railing kills for excitement, and tons of 80s big hair. Just add in some power ballads and 80s Starship and you’ve got a mega hit.

       5 likes

  5. Fart Bargo says:

    Creeping Terror the Musical!

    A musical along the lines of Little Shop of Horrors. Nice slow numbers though for people escaping and being consumed by the Terror.

       4 likes

  6. Pulatso says:

    I Accuse My Parents.

       3 likes

  7. JK Robertson says:

    I always thought The Brain That Wouldn’t Die would make a cool musical. Kind of on par with Little Shop of Horrors. Plus, who wouldn’t pay to see Jan in the Pan as a belter!

       3 likes

  8. Dark Grandma of Death says:

    The Skydivers. There’s already a musical number in place, and even now I can see the skydiving scenes set on a stage….

       2 likes

  9. Patrick says:

    I Accuse My Parents. Pure theater gold!

       4 likes

  10. Sitting Duck says:

    Jack Frost, as adapting it into a Broadway musical is probably the only way to make it even goofier.

       1 likes

  11. Canucklehead says:

    Hired! the Musical…

    But as for full movies into Broadway, I think that someone should bring the Big Green Guy to the Great White Way. I now present to you,

    Godzilla vs. Megalon, the Musical!

    What do you think, sirs?

       2 likes

  12. Steve A. Laimo says:

    The Incredibly Strange Creatures Who Stopped Living and Became Mixed-Up Zombies – The Musical! I could see Paul Ruebens assuming the role made famous by Cash Flagg. The guy from “The Most Interesting Man in the World” commercials would make a fabulous Ortega!!

       6 likes

  13. Zee says:

    I would turn VIKING WOMEN VS. THE SEA SERPENT into a hit musical. Think of the chorus girls, with the furry bathmat viking girl outfits… Grrrr!

       1 likes

  14. Once Upon A Honeymoon: it already has singing and Wilbur is just to fabulous not to be on broadway.

       1 likes

  15. fonyo says:

    “Horrors of Spider Island.” They already have the “dancers.” The endless refrain, Gary, Gary, Gary, the two french guys, and BABS!

       2 likes

  16. Smirkboy says:

    NINETY DEGREES! It’s 9:15 AM and it’s already ninety degrees outside-Oh, a musical? Let me see. . .Hmmmmm.

    “BRIDE OF THE MONSTER”

    I can see Lobo’s charming soliloquy of regret for not helping the pretty lady sooner: “Lobo could have been contender instead of bum what Lobo is.”

    Henry Rollins as Dr. Eric Vornoff

    David Hasselhoff as Lobo

    Hugh Jackman as Lt. DICK Craig

    Anna Paquinn as Janet

    E. Emmet Walsh
    or Brian Dennehy
    or Wilford Brimly as Captain Tom Robbins

    Will Ferrel as Kelton

    Judd Hirsch as Dr. as Prof. Vladimir Strowski

    Cathy Bates as Tillie (with and without pencil)

    Lady Gaga as Margie

    And Artie Lange as The Drunk

       3 likes

  17. digital_trucker says:

    The answer is obvious, of course.

    Hamlet.

       6 likes

  18. Stressfactor says:

    “Untamed Youth” practically already is a musical.

       1 likes

  19. Edwin B says:

    Girl’s town! Of course you would have to replace the deadly dull songs like Ava Maria. Lindsey Lohan as Silver Morgan,
    Justin Bieber as Jimmy Parlow, and instead of the Platters the Black Eyed Peas are the entertainment at the club.

       1 likes

  20. Brandon says:

    MITCHELL!

    Can you picture the scene where Mitchell and that hooker are making out (UGH), and there’s a chorus off to the side singing, “Oh my, my,my, my Mitchell!”

       4 likes

  21. Droppo says:

    My, my, my, my Mitchell!

       1 likes

  22. Droppo says:

    Great minds…

       3 likes

  23. Laura says:

    Gunslinger. You already have the dancing girls and maybe have people singing during the bar fight.

       2 likes

  24. AlbuquerqueTurkey says:

    I immediately thought “Jack Frost”. The play would be a costumer’s dream; Hunchback Fairy’s house on chicken legs would be a marvelous set design, as would Frost’s house; you could appropriate the great Russian music soundtrack for much of the play; and a lyricist would have a blast converting that goofy story to song. And it would make for a great street show at the Macy’s Parade – can you imagine Ivan dancing with Hunchback Fairy and the Talking Trees doing their big showstopper, “I’m Going to Eat You”! ! It’s Big, it’s Bold, it’s Brassy and Sassy, it’s a Musical Humdinger!

       1 likes

  25. Charlie G says:

    @ JK Robertson,7

    The Brain That Wouldn’t Die HAS been made into a musical

    http://headthemusical.com/

    Though technically not broadway buuuuut

       1 likes

  26. trickymutha says:

    Fugitive Alien. Can’t wait for the big closing number- “They tried to kill him with a forklift” Any ideas who might play Captain Joe the lush?

       3 likes

  27. The the Eye Creatures says:

    GAMERA THE MUSICAL!!!!!

       2 likes

  28. rockiemtnriff says:

    Pumaman!! One of the songs could be sung to the Doors tune “Backdoor Man”.

       1 likes

  29. Mr. B(ob) says:

    An obvious choice would be Catalina Caper. It’s already music based, even if the music wasn’t so hot. The whole movie is a lame excuse for a lame musical dance party. Write some better music for it, or deliberately comical songs of higher quality than the original and you’ve got a show.

    A less obvious choice would be, oh I don’t know, say, The Crawling Hand. Imagine songs expressing the emotions of a severed limb and its uncontrollable desire to kill, kill, kill! And the movie did have a romance plot between the young main character and his girlfriend. It would be klandinktu!

       3 likes

  30. I'm not a medium, I'm a petite says:

    Tormented. ( srsly )

       1 likes

  31. “The answer is obvious, of course.

    Hamlet. ”

    Great Idea, the Gilligan’s Island episode could provide a good starting point.

       2 likes

  32. Fart Bargo says:

    TM @26 I would recommend Gary Oldham. He can do the sudden emotional changes real well. See The Professional

       1 likes

  33. The DA says:

    Eegah! the Broadway Musical! Please, no Arch Hall, Jr. songs in this one!

       6 likes

  34. Ryan says:

    #17, Nah, it’d never work.

    I LOVE the idea of MST3K: The Movie turned into a musical. The song about Tom’s underwear collection would be epic!

       1 likes

  35. hollyhox says:

    The Day the Earth Froze. Can’t you just see the giant show-stopping number? “We failed to bring back the Sampo! We will die of starvation! Failure, failure, failure, failure, failure, failure…”

       1 likes

  36. Manos has already been used as a play, no reason it shouldn’t be taken to broadway!

       5 likes

  37. The Screaming Skull.

    It was a rainy night, and he shot her.
    It was a rainy night and she got dead.

    Too easy, really, since there’s only five characters and you’d only need one set.

    Mickey! We’re looking for Mickey!

       4 likes

  38. Farmland says:

    San Francisco International, just for the climatic finale where Pernell signs the stupid kid down.

       2 likes

  39. Farmland says:

    Oops, that’s “sings”…

       0 likes

  40. Samson vs. the Vampire Women could be very operatic. Heck, are there any MST3K movies that *wouldn’t* make a good Broadway musical? Well, I guess Squirm would present some serious technical challenges.

       1 likes

  41. Dark Grandma of Death says:

    Clark Stooksbury says:

    “The answer is obvious, of course.

    Hamlet. ”

    Great Idea, the Gilligan’s Island episode could provide a good starting point.
    ****

    That’s exactly the thought that came to mind. I remember that episode vividly (and pathetically). Great…now I have the whole Harold Hecuba thing stuck in my head!

       1 likes

  42. klisch says:

    Castle of Fu Manchu.

       0 likes

  43. Cabbage Patch Elvis says:

    Well, we’ve already seen a preview for Teenage Strangler, with Mike Nelson’s “I’m a Janitor” performance sure to be a highlight.

    For high-wire wrestling action, I’d like to suggest Racket Girls.

    But I really think The Sinister Urge would make for a truly surreal experience, with lots of dramatic musical numbers where the characters each lament their descent into porn…

       2 likes

  44. AgentMom says:

    Well, the answer is obvious for the first one! Fugitive Alien!

    And it even has a great song already ready to go!

    This is the song written for the train chase.
    This is the chase, Rocky and Ken.
    He tried to kill me with a forklift.
    Olé!

    Now strap in tight; let’s get set for action;
    To launch the ship up off the sand.
    He tried to kill me with a forklift.
    Huzzah!

    Next, Werewolf, which already has two great songs going. “Where or Werewolf,” and of course “TUSK!”

    Then, we have Pod People, with a great song by the Joel and the bots with a memorable hook line that will become a sensation! “IT STINKS!” Later the crowd will be brought to tears as the spotlight hits Joel and he belts out “The Clown in the Sky!” Joel will bring the house down!

    Finally, I give that Christmas Classic that will leave children traumatized for all time, Santa Clause Conquers the Martians. There’s only one song in this musical, but it goes on forever and you will think it will NEVER stop!

    S-A-N-T-A, C-L-A-U-S
    Hooray for Santy Claus!

    You spell it S-A-N-T-A, C-L-A-U-S
    Hooray for Santy Claus

    Hooray for Santy Claus
    Yay yay for Santy Claus
    He’s fat and round, but jumpin’ jiminy
    He can climb down any chiminy!
    When we hear sleigh bells ring
    Our hearts go ting-a-ling
    ‘Cause there’ll be presents under the tree
    Hooray for Santy Claus!

    Now all year long at the North Pole
    He’s busy making toys
    But he knows just what you’re doin’
    So you better be good girls and boys!

    Hang up that mistletoe
    Soon you’ll hear Ho Ho Ho
    On Christmas Day, you’ll wake up and you’ll say
    Hooray for Santy Claus!

    Yay yay! Yay yay!
    Yay yay! HOORAY!!!

    Hang up that mistletoe
    Soon you’ll hear Ho Ho Ho
    On Christmas Day, you’ll wake up and you’ll say
    Hooray for Santy Claus!

    S-A-N-T-A, C-L-A-U-S
    Hooray for Santy Claus!

    You spell it S-A-N-T-A, C-L-A-U-S
    Hooray for Santy Claus!

    Hoo-raaaaayy forrr Sannn-tyyyy Clauuuusss!

    Hooray for Santy Claus
    CHA CHA CHA!!!!!

       2 likes

  45. Creepygirl says:

    I second TEENAGE STRANGLER. Mikey was born for the stage and “Yike Stripes” will have them dancing in the aisles.

       2 likes

  46. Cabbage Patch Elvis says:

    Teenagers from Outer Space: SpaceLobsterFest! starring Neil Patrick Harris as Derrick and Winona Ryder as Betty, Ed Asner as Grandpa and Kevin Spacey as Thor!

       2 likes

  47. Righty says:

    I think I Acusse my Parents would work the best. They’ve already got songs wihtin the movie.

       1 likes

  48. eegah says:

    Oh, come on people. The best one would be “The Final Sacrifice”. It screams musical.

       1 likes

  49. Kathy says:

    The obvious choice: “The Girl in Lover’s Lane”. Half “Zorba”…half “Best Little Whorehouse In Texas”?

    Meanwhile….

    “The Brain That Wouldn’t Die HAS been made into a musical

    Though technically not broadway buuuuut”

    Thanks for the link but…WTF with these guys??? “…based on Roger Corman’s 1962 gore-fest The Brain That Wouldn’t Die..”

    I had more to do with that film than Corman…and I was three years old when it was made. This is like everyone on the internet thinking that all parody songs were written by Weird Al.

       1 likes

  50. Edwin B says:

    # 49 – Sounds good, but only if they change the ending and Kerri lives, right? Otherwise it would be too depressing!

       1 likes

Comments are closed.